Sketch of Geoffrey Klempner


Ask a Philosopher was launched in 1999 on the University of Sheffield web site. Since then, we have responded to thousands of questions submitted from all over the world. In 2006 Ask a Philosopher moved to

This service is offered courtesy of Pathways to Philosophy, the independent distance learning project run by the International Society for Philosophers.

Go to for the latest questions and answers. Your question is more likely to be answered if you show that you have thought about the problem and are not just asking us to do your homework for you. For advice on formulating your question see below.

Ask a question

Answer a question

Are you looking for someone to talk to about philosophy? If you are on Facebook why not join the International Society for Philosophers open group? Or register now with

View the latest Questions and Answers

Answer a question

Philosophy graduates and teachers are invited to contribute their expertise. If you would like to help, you are welcome to email your response to any of the questions posted on the Questions page to

The latest questions are also distributed by email to members of the Ask a Philosopher panel. If you would like to join the panel, please email, including a brief CV and statement of your academic qualifications.

Please note that this is an opportunity to show how philosophers think — what is a philosophical approach to a question — and not simply to sound off about your own pet theory. There is too much of that on the internet already.


To increase the likelihood of your question being answered

  • Check with previous questions and answers to see if your particular question has been answered before. You might want to add to the question or respond to a previous answer.

  • If you are having difficulty with an essay or course work, try to put the question in your own words rather than simply writing down the question you have been set.

  • Tell us if you have any ideas about how your question might be tackled. We like to see that you have tried to think the question through for yourself before coming for help.

  • Try to think of something interesting or original to ask. If the best question you can come up with is 'Why?' or, 'Is this a question?' then don't bother because we've heard it.


Problems removed

Try the Pathways Problem Removal Service if your problem is more practical in nature. We can give advice in identifying and solving your problem. In certain circumstances, we are also prepared to offer practical help.

We are not agony aunts, and we can't promise that you will like the advice that we give.


More Q and A (Ask a Philosopher) (Tentative Answers) (Electronic Philosopher)

Thank you for taking the time to visit these pages.

Geoffrey Klempner
Director of Studies


Answer pages
(2nd series)

page 1      page 2
page 3      page 4
page 5      page 6
page 7      page 8
page 9     page 10
page 11   page 12
page 13   page 14
page 15   page 16
page 17   page 18
page 19   page 20
page 21   page 22
page 23   page 24
page 25   page 26
page 27   page 28
page 29   page 30
page 31   page 32
page 33   page 34
page 35   page 36
page 37   page 38
page 39   page 40
page 41   page 42
page 43   page 44
page 45   page 46
page 47   page 48
page 49

Answer pages
(1st series)

page 1
page 2
page 3
page 4
page 5
page 6
page 7
page 8
page 9
page 10
page 11
page 12
page 13
page 14
page 15
page 16
page 17
page 18
page 19
page 20
page 21
page 22
page 23
page 24

Pathways to Philosophy

Letters to my students
How-to-do-it guide
Essay archive
Pathways programs

Pathways teaching materials © G. Klempner 1995–2015
'Sketch' © June Wynter 1999